Welcome to Seeing Sociology, a blog by students in "Introduction to Sociology" at Lewis and Clark College.
Wednesday, November 19, 2014
The video above draws on privilege white people have over African Americans. While Whites are more likely to get jobs, go to college, and be perceived as sophisticated over African Americans, when researching instances of in-prison racism and white privilege nothing came up except for statistics of White versus Black incarceration rates. This not only made me frustrated but it also made me angry. Why is this? Why is there no records of in-prison white privilege? While my cousin, a cop, from Thousand Oaks, California, believes its simply because it does not exist, I'm not so captured by the idea.
We know that African Americans make up 12.5-14% of the US population, but it is unbelievable that 38% of this population of African Americans are incarcerated for many offenses white people have often gotten away with. For example, 5 times as many Whites are using drugs as African Americans, yet African Americans are sent to prison for drug offenses at 10 times the rate of Whites. African Americans are also incarcerated for any given crime at nearly six times the rate of whites. This is hardly astonishing as white privilege is a current and an unending institution in the United States. But as I said, there is no evidence of racism or white privilege existing inside prison walls, which can be explained by one thing, and one thing only: when it comes to knowledge of white privilege in prison not being announced to the public it is “cuz the white man said so.” Said by Watson in the first season of Orange is the new black. It is perfectly possible for inmates complaints of white privilege or quiet racism to be muffled by the prison system itself, as inmates have no rights, and are constantly beaten for misbehavior or attitude against what is “rightful” treatment of prisoners. Orange is the New Black may be a distorted and more pleasant look on prison life, but it still asks its audience to consider certain issues that are overlooked or unknown by the U.S. population. "In 2011-12, an estimated 4.0% of state and federal prison inmates and 3.2% of jail inmates reported experiencing one or more incidents of sexual victimization by another inmate or facility staff in the past 12 months or since admission to the facility, if less than 12 months,” although this is lower than expected since many sexual assault victims never come forward. This shows that much of the “drama” that makes up Orange is the New Black, is drawn from real life statistics and encounters by inmates in real prison institutions, so we can conclude that, although we have no sufficient evidence proving white privilege or quiet racism inside prison systems exists, the fact that no one is talking about it or question the institution means that maybe prison systems have something to hide regarding such issues. Monday, November 17, 2014
Whats going on with our public schools?
Approximately, 3,000 students, 1 college councilor, 10 class advisors, and an average of 40 to 50 students in each class. This was my experience at a public high school in southern California. There was little staff or resources available to students and opportunities continued to decline as the district LAUSD received numerous budget cuts. As a result, many students did not receive a good education, classes were too full, there wasn't enough funding for science projects, and there was no one on one time with teachers.
Total Per-Student Expenditures Versus Student Poverty Rates for U.S. School Districts with More Than 1,000 Enrollment
Source: Prepared using information from the Common Core of Data for 1995, School District Data Book, National Center for Education Statistics (2000b).
This graph shows the relationship between low income students and the amount of money allotted from the government to each student. Many minority students live in these areas and would explain the correlation of minority students that go on to college. As a result, these students have to face more difficulties than students who have a private school education.
I went to a predominantly Hispanic high
school and during the college application process, every day I saw one my
friends ruining their lives because they didn’t think they could get in to
college or they didn’t have the ability to pay for it. It was until I got to college that I have
been reflecting on this experience. The only
reason I was able to prepare a good college application and get a private
school education is because my parents were motivated and got the information
that we needed to succeed. Otherwise, I
would have been another one of those kids trying to find my way through the
complicated politics and information of the college world. Although I have always admired the staff at
my public high school, there was just simply not enough resources and
information given to the students for them to succeed. We wonder why there isn’t a lot of diversity
on a lot of college campuses. We are led
to believe that a minority student going to college is someone who is rising up
against the social norms, which is why we put this on our college
application. Apparently, it is something
“unique” and “special” for a Hispanic woman to get a higher education. It is it precisely this type of thinking that
discourages minority children to seek out higher education. There are ways to
pay for college and get good grades, but unfortunately nobody knows about them.
The Distortion of Feminism Through Social Media
![]() |
| http://time.com/3576870/worst-words-poll-2014/ |
It seems that the decline of feminism as a legitimate
agenda can be traced to the rise of social media. The topics of sexism and feminism have been trending among social media users lately, especially through platforms like Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, and Upworthy. In a way, having these widely accessed websites addressing these issues can be positive. It attempts to illustrate the scope of sexism to the masses, many of whom are never subjected to this reality. However, there is an issue with this type of social media bringing attention to sexism. The danger arises when popularization, notnecessarily understanding, develops around the issue and it becomes a trend for self-proclaimed and often misinformed "feminists" to briefly address. The internet has made it possible to popularize a cause without actually doing anything. Now, by simply retweeting and reblogging, anyone can publicize their opinions. In turn, the public is presented with a conglomeration of miseducated "feminists" as leaders of the movement rather than serious feminist activists who may lack the same social media presence. Feminism has been popularized as a bandwagon cause and I'm still unsure as to whether the attention brought to the cause is helpful or harmful. Media attention is media attention—even if people don't agree with certain claims about gender inequality, at least they are exposed to the topic. However, because these this corrupted "internet feminism" most often generates buzz and conversation rather than understanding and action, I see the deep-rooted and very real issue of sexism being cheapened and commodified through social media. Many corporations and celebrities have begun to endorse feminism, only adding to the bandwagon appeal. By simply acknowledging gender inequality, it seems like these celebrities assume that they are enacting change or making some controversial, edgy statement. This example set by celebrities is projected to the public who in turn believe that by simply being aware of sexism, that they are contributing to the cause. At this point, feminism doesn't need more internet buzz or celebrity attention, feminism needs solidarity, dedication, and action.
Within the past few months, several viral videos attempting to explain and demonstrate street harassment have captured public attention. Most of these videos attempt "reverse the roles" of sexism to show how badly this issue affects women. Though the initial videos that prompted this trend intended to be serious, they generated comedic responses that gained even more attention. The predominant flaw I see in these videos is the entire concept of role reversal. The roles don't need to be reversed because sexism affects both men and women. While it is true that more women are subject to catcalling and verbal harassment than men are, these videos offer an incomplete, one-sided argument about sexism. Also, using comedy to address such an issue can make it more accessible to the public, but at the same time it undermines and trivializes a serious social problem. I am not condemning feminism; I support it whole-heartedly. I am, however, condemning "feminists" who believe they are solving anything through generating harassment/abuse back towards men. These actions are not only irrational, but they also corrupt the public perception of modern feminism and undermine the intentions of informed and serious equal rights activists. At this point, I don't think simply "making a statement" (especially through comedy/trivialization) is a productive avenue if we are serious about enacting a legitimate change in the way our society contributes to sexism.Eating Disorders and The Media
There are many different types of eating disorders and reasons why people adopt them. The two most common disorders are anorexia nervousa and bulimia nervosa. Anorexia nervosa causes people to have a distorted body image where they think they're overweight when in reality they're dangerously thin. People with this disorder often refuse to eat, exercise compulsively, and develop unusual habits such as refusing to eat in front of other people. Individuals with bulimia nervosa eat excessive quantities, then purge their bodies of the food and calories they fear by using laxatives, enemas, vomiting, or exercising.
Women are much more likely than men to develop an eating disorder. Only an estimated 5 to 15 percent of people with anorexia or bulimia are male. An estimated 0.5 to 3.7 percent of women suffer from anorexia in their lifetime. An estimated 1.1 to 4.2 percent of women have bulimia in their lifetime. Teens and young adults between the ages of 12 and 26 make up 95 percent of those who have an eating disorder. Anorexia is the most common cause of death among young women ages 15 to 24.
The media is one of the largest culprits for eating disorders. Mass media provides a significantly influential context for people to learn about body ideals and the value placed on being attractive. The effect of media on women's body dissatisfaction, thin ideal internalization, and disordered eating appears to be stronger among young adults than children and adolescents. Pressure from mass media to be muscular also appears to be related to body dissatisfaction among men. Magazine covers like the image above display unrealistic bodies and give off the illusion that if you don't have a body like this you're not considered beautiful. Magazine covers like this give the wrong impression to young children, because contrary to popular belief you can still be beautiful without being as skinny as the women on the covers. 47% of girls in the 5th-12th grade reported wanted to lose weight because of magazine pictures. 69% of girls in the 5th-12th grade reported that magazine pictures influenced their idea of a perfect body shape. 42% of 1st-3rd grade girls want to be thinner. 81% of 10 year olds are afraid of being fat. These statistics are extremely concerning. Due to the exposure at a young age to such unrealistic ideals girls as young as the age of 10 fear weight problems.
Although not all media contributes to unrealistic ideal of how a women should look. The video above is a campaign from the skin care company, Dove. The campaign, Real Beauty, was launched in 2004 in response to the findings of a major global study that revealed that only 2% of women around the world would describe themselves as beautiful. The main goal of the campaign is to "change the status quo and offer in its place a broader, healthier, more democratic view of beauty." In this specific video Dove is trying to send a message to the artists that manipulate photos by releasing a Photoshop action called "Beautify" that reverts images to their original state and overlays a banner proclaiming "don't manipulate our perceptions of real beauty." More companies should follow in the footsteps of Dove and work toward ending eating disorders instead of contribute to them.
Thursday, November 13, 2014
The picture on the left is the cover of Paper magazine which was
released on November 11, 2014 portraying Kim Kardashian. The image on the right
is of Grace Jones placed in a collection entitled Jungle Fever by the photographer of both photos;
Jean Paul Gaude. The primary focus of both photos is the fact that both women
can balance a champagne glass on their behinds. Whether it is obvious or not,
Gaude altered the photos in order to extend the behinds of both models in order
for the champagne glass to sit comfortably. The original photo of Grace brings
about concerning issues about race due to the fetishization of Grace's body as
an archetype of the stereotypical "black female body". The archetype
of the black female body as having dark skin, a naturally curvy figure
(accentuated by the edited butt), and maybe not as present in this photo but
unique hair. The fetishization of black women is then perpetuated through not
only the name of the book in which this image was published but as well as the
images that are along side this image. The fact that the book is called Jungle Fever is a racial term to describe
someone who is interested in black individuals, therefor giving Grace the
spotlight in order to falsely represent an image for black women.
In lieu of the background concerning the
fetishization of Grace Jones's body. The question that must be asked is why Kim
Kardashian was placed as the model for Paper magazine instead? Kim Kardashian's
celebrity status can be easily attributed to her sex appeal, but mainly the
appeal of her behind. As previously stated the fetishization of Grace Jones, as
well as black women in general is to have a curvy figure, in this portrayal the
curvy figure is accentuated by a big behind. Kim Kardashian was chosen for this
photo because of her close proximity to the archetype of a black woman. It is
also key to understand what is lacking from the black archetype that Kim
Kardashian is embodying. Black woman have been recognized as the least
desirable race, while white women on the other hand are recognized as more if
not the most desirable. Therefor recreating the image with a white woman
embodying the archetype of black woman's body is more desirable, gaining more
publicity.
Jokes are all over the internet, on Reddit, Facebook, and other sites that distribute these “ memes”. Many places now, children are growing up reading these posts about “ traps”. A trap is someone who was assigned male at birth and presents as female, the implication behind this is that this “ trap” is trying to trick a male into believing they are a women. These jokes no matter how insensitive and offensive are often talked about as just jokes.
However, these jokes are a marker of our society’s thoughts on transgendered people. 
The respondents to these were thousands of trans men and women. The statistics of violence on trans people are staggering. This is because our society has adopted the norm to look at trans people as “traps”. When we look at these statistics of trans issues in the same view as rape and violence toward women. We quickly see that society has deemed it ok, for assault and domination to be enacted upon trans people. Over half of trans women will experience sexual assault. It is almost expected for a trans women to be assaulted in our culture today, yet our conversation on the topic is very limited.
My perspective may come into play, for I am a trans women, when I state that these acts of violence are normalized and perpetuated by these jokes. In movies such as “White Girls”
where men dress as women to as a means to achieve people for their end goal, or there is an idea in many portrayals of cross dressing and trans women in cartoons, as only trying to trick a male into “believing she is biologically female”. we perpetuate the idea that trans identities are not real, and only used to achieve an end.
These statistics seem to indicate then that our reaction in real life to this “trickery” shown in the media is violence and discrimination. There are very obvious acts such as beatings, and sexual assault, but it also reaches deeper into our everyday conversation. When transgender people are deliberately misgendered it is an act of violence. While the physical threat or sexual domination is not present, it does push home the idea that the cultural does not see them as the gender they are, therefore dehumanizing them by invalidating their identity. Deliberate misgendering is very present in our society, in things such as movies and jokes, this causes harm to the individual. I have no qualms in saying the rate of suicide is the result of society’s portrayal and view of trans and can be changed. This act of continual dehumanization and invalidation, is a constant reminder that society thinks they are “tricking” people about their identity and acts of violence both sexual and physical encourage suicide. It suggest that society does not want them around. When one is under constant threat based on their own identity it becomes societies problem when these people die and not necessarily mental illness. In fact up until the recent addition of the DSM (The Diagnostic and statistical manual), which is used to diagnose mental illnesses, being trans was labeled as a mental disorder, a course of thought many health professionals still sadly use. As a culture we must address this discrimination.
These statistics are often 5 and even 40 times higher than national averages. I will again highlight my perspective as a trans woman myself, I can not see a way in which we can progress in human rights in our country without trying to drastically change the perception of transgender in our media and our speech. It is a danger to many people and can generate constant fear in the lives of thousands. For very good reasons. The threat of not only discrimination but violence, death, and suicidal tendencies is a result of our mockery and what seems like distrust and disgust of trans based in many parts of our society.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








